“Kayleen Seidl is absolutely superb as Maria. Ms. Seidl's exceptional performance of the title song and "My Favorite Things" with Cáitlín Burke, who portrays Mother Abbess, will leave you smiling from ear to ear.”

— BroadwayWorld.com

”And, of course, there was the effervescent and angelic Maria Rainer.  Kayleen Seidl’s version of this famous character was pure joy.  Her beautiful tone of voice matched the famous songs we all know so well, all while making them feel playful and new.” 

— TheTheatreGuide.com

“She charms the audience as she moves effortlessly across the stage. When she sings, her amazing vocal performance soars through the theater capturing and lifting the audience. On opening night we witnessed a future Broadway star on the Westchester stage.”

— IOnTheValley.com

“[Seidl] who captivates The Phantom with her Lily Pons pyrotechnical voice, sings coloratura high notes effortlessly…I kept thinking she would not be able to top her showstopper ‘Home’ in the first act, but I was wrong!”

— BroadwayWorld.com

“Powerful duets and a playful dance number shared between [Matthew Taylor and Kayleen Seidl] were highlights of the production, as was watching Seidl take her character from lady to “doll” and back again through a transformative vocal performance.”

— OCInsite.com

“[Seidl] makes the role her own, using moments of quiet intensity that work effectively to offset the scenes where the wild inner Sarah Brown finally breaks loose.”

— Spokesman.com

“Seidl’s Laurey is more than pretty and confused about men; she’s really conceivable as a very young woman holding down a farm.”

— BroadwayWorld.com

Showboat

“Kayleen Seidl, in the female leading role of Magnolia, is another wonderful singer, with a soaring soprano voice that is pure, and sweet. This belle not only sings well, she's got the acting chops to match.”

— Captivasanibel.com